I, a Christian, Admit It: Atheists Have Been Right All Along

by John Shore on November 5, 2009 · 54 comments

blind

Here's a standard Christian youth camp indoctrination game we like to call Follow Jesus.

Atheists: I hereby declare that you are right. I give up trying to pretend otherwise. You win. You’ve got my number. Despite everything I’ve been saying and writing for years, you know the truth, and your laser-like focus upon that truth has finally burned through my facade of deception.

So here, finally, is the truth I’ve been too long denying: All Christians are, in fact, ignorant, narrow-minded, self-righteous, intolerant, intrusive, hypocritical, fear-driven, gay-hating, misogynistic, money-grubbing, imperialistic war-mongers. And you’re right about all Christians thinking and believing exactly alike. We do. We’ve all been thoroughly indoctrinated into the machine of Organized Religion (which is the only kind of religion we care capable of liking or understanding), and are at least once a week brainwashed by our craven, egomaniacal Pastor Overlords into directly correlating our self-worth with how much money and allegiance we pledge to The Church. We’re like helpless children desperately eager to hand over responsibility for our lives to Our Leaders, in whom we unquestionably believe. We’re absolutely incapable of independent or rational thought. That’s why the mere sight of a chart of elements or a microscope makes us react like chimps being poked at with lit torches. The simple fact is that science terrifies us.

We fear knowledge.

There. I said it. And I feel so much better!

The sole reason I ever pretended to care or be interested in anything you ever said, atheists, is because I was trying to lure you into becoming part of the Christian Borg. How else could I tolerate your soulless prattle? Besides relinquishing our money and time to The Church, we Christians are programmed for one thing, and one thing only: the recruitment of fresh blood into our ranks. Each Sunday every pastor tells every Christian in his congregation how many people they’re responsible for recruiting that week. If by the following Sunday a Christian has failed to meet that week’s personal conversion quota (PCQ), he or she must do penance by washing and detailing the pastor’s car right after the service. That’s why pastors’ cars always look so great. It’s amazing what a little Turtle Wax and a lot of guilt can accomplish.

I want to thank you, atheists, for finally breaking down my barriers, and allowing me to admit that you’ve been right all along. None of we Christians are intellectually curious, genuinely compassionate, congenitally independent, or more interested in truth than doctrine. You were right to insist that we’re all exactly alike, despite all the faux-evidence that we take pains to everywhere provide you to the contrary. Some people say that bigotry and blindly stereotyping groups of others is lazy, stupid and caustically arrogant. But I think it’s safe to say that, in my case anyway, you have absolutely and finally proven its value.


 

11prayerofweek
Subscribe to John’s Prayer for the Week and/or John’s Monthly Newsletter here. (Read a bit more about them here).

{ 54 comments… read them below or add one }

1 2

Cadie March 31, 2012 at 8:06 pm

I’m beginning to see more and more….

Reply

Jay March 7, 2011 at 5:36 pm

Wow, so you have just taken a group identified solely by what they do not believe and you have extrapolated from that some astoundingly specific beliefs for a very large and diverse group of people. Now I understand the instinct to become defensive when someone tells you that you are wrong about something as fundamental as the nature of the universe. And with the increasing popularity and boldness of popular atheists I can see how confidence can sometimes be mistaken or even turn into smug self righteousness. But as An scientific person, as many atheists are, I respect logic and evidence and it does not logically follow that because we are right about this one thing, we are better than you in general. It is simply a non sequitur. Indeed there are atheists and christians who believe as represented in the above caricatures of them but they are two flavors or the same problem. I’ll promise not to prejudge you based on your favorite book if you promise not to make it my responsibility to defend actions that I don’t condone of people I don’t agree with.

Reply

Allie April 1, 2012 at 2:39 am

Way to miss the point, Jay.

Reply

Grace December 9, 2010 at 11:24 pm

Right. And likewise, you, sir, are completely right lumping all atheists into one category as Christian-hating narrow-minded bigots.

I don’t say “There is no God.” I’m thirteen. I have absolutely no idea whether there is a god or not, as I probably won’t be any more enlightened when I die. However, I feel no personal need for a god. However, you obviously do. It fills a void for you that it doesn’t for me. And as I respect that, I think you should respect my choice as well.

But what do I know. I’m just a cynical heartless god-hating dream-crushing loveless atheist. So take it with a grain of salt.

Reply

tony baldwin October 23, 2010 at 6:25 pm

As an atheist, I would never stereotype all Christians as ignorant, sheepish automatons. Maybe most of them, but certainly not all of them.
I have a regular dialogue with various Christians who are my friends and family.
Some of them are very progressive, compassionate, intelligent people (other than their irrational faith in supernatural beings, that is).
I also concur that the loudest “Christians”, being those in the religious right (beck, palin, et al.) are decidedly NOT representative of those who truly aim to follow the teachings of your Jesus. I have read the Bible, and, while it does, in instances, seem to advocate genocide, rape, slavery, domestic violence, etc., Jesus, himself, seemed to advocate nothing more than nonjudgmental, unconditional love and compassion, and I do believe that there ARE Christians who make a concerted effort to follow those teachings. Quakers would be a good example. I actually go and meditate with Quakers on occasion (I understand their worship isn’t exactly meditation, but they don’t seem to mind me meditating in their Meetings).

Reply

Sea Sick Sailor October 22, 2010 at 12:24 am

Crap. I thought I was great a sarcasim. I bow to the master.

Reply

Christopher Berman August 18, 2010 at 11:10 pm

Whoo for a ridiculous straw-man that, ironically, perpetuates exactly what it is you are trying to combat.

Reply

Monica Smothers May 1, 2010 at 9:53 am

Well, as a pretty young atheist(I'm 28), I'm going to say this:

While what you was said was funny, not all atheists think that way. Lumping us together is kinda like lumping Christians together(yes, I'm a former Happy Clappy, try and figure that one out)and while I may not agree with your theology…I don't think you deserve it either. That being said, I don't it really kicked up any major type of debate more or less. Just a bunch of sycophants who say "well, atheists are just as much of a bunch of asses as everyone else".

And to the Believing Agnostic. That's your opinion love, and here is mine: if you are a Believing Agnositc, you're just a Believer with doubts. That's all. Sure many philosophies can be stretched to fit the person, but you're about to break the comfy-fit rubber band ;P.

That being said: There is a time and place for blanket statements. I just don't know if this was the best time.

This entry didn't really make me think that I should treat my fellow believers any differently or even make me question my somewhat Godless ways.

But it did make me laugh.

Reply

John Shore May 2, 2010 at 1:28 am

Hey, Monica. Not that it matters, but this post was really written for my longer-time readers, insofar as, in the past, I've written copious amounts of stuff which is all about how and why atheists generally deserve our respect. They would know that–and would know … how those efforts have been generally received. I was really just blowing off a little steam here; this post is hardly typical of what I do here on my blog. Sometimes I forget that new readers wouldn't have any reason to know stuff like that.

Reply

Dennis Dawson May 1, 2010 at 7:08 am

Mr. Dennis Dawson is an ass. Don't listen to him.

I'm sure there are many, many atheists who are inferior and fallible in their thinking, and that is the sincere truthiness. I don't agree with Mr. Dennis Dawson's opinion, either, and I am also an atheist.

Mr. Dennis Dawson is still going to hell, though. You betcha.

Reply

John Shore May 2, 2010 at 1:30 am

I went to high school with a guy named Dennis Dawson, of whom I was very fond. He was a bit of a schizophrenic, though.

Reply

Brad from kentucky April 30, 2010 at 10:41 pm

Um…isn’t it obvious to anyone else that the point being made here is that everyone is different no matter their belief? Mr. Dennis Dawson is arrogant in saying that “No atheist believes that all Christians are the same or think the same way”. That’s basically saying all atheists are superior and are infallible in their thinking and this is a falsehood and a hypocrisy. I don’t agree with Mr. Dawson’s opinion and I am also an atheist.

Reply

1 2

Leave a Comment